Showing posts with label Southern Economic Journal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Southern Economic Journal. Show all posts

Sunday, April 25, 2021

Hayek Attempts to Resolve the Dilemma between Equilibrium Theory and the Disequilibrium Associated with Business Cycles

In Monetary Theory and the Trade Cycle, Hayek draws attention to the deficiency of equilibrium theory to explain “why a general disproportionality between supply and demand should arise.” The solution to this problem, Hayek notes, is not to be found by changes originating within the equilibrium construct nor by the methods of equilibrium analysis since “the essential means of explanation in static theory . . . is the assumption that prices supply an automatic mechanism for equilibrating supply and demand.” In resolving the dilemma between equilibrium theory and the disequilibrium associated with business cycles, Hayek argues that it is only the introduction of money that can provide a “new determining cause” capable of explaining “the difference between the course of events described by static theory . . . and the actual course of events.” The introduction of money, Hayek tells us, “does away with the rigid interdependence and self-sufficiency of the ‘closed’ system of equilibrium and makes possible movements which would be excluded from the latter.” . . . 

My remarks perhaps come in somewhat sharper relief if we examine Hayek’s discussion of neutral money in the Appendix to Lecture IV of Prices and Production. In general, neutral money is employed by Hayek to describe a monetary economy that has achieved a constellation of relative prices as if money were not present; it would involve an economy fully specifiable by equilibrium theory. In reflecting on the suitability of the neutral money concept as an objective of monetary policy, Hayek says:

. . . the term points, of course, only to a problem, and does not represent a solution. . . . The necessary starting point for any attempt to answer the theoretical problem seems to me to be the recognition of the fact that the identity of demand and supply, which must necessarily exist in the case of barter, ceases to exist as soon as money becomes the intermediary of the exchange transaction. The problem then becomes one of isolating the one-sided effects of money . . . which will appear when, after the division of the barter transaction into separate transactions, one of these takes place without the other complementary transaction. In this sense, demand without corresponding supply, and supply without a corresponding demand, evidently seem to occur. . . . 

—William N. Butos, “Hayek and General Equilibrium Analysis,” Southern Economic Journal 52, no. 2 (October 1985): 338.


Sunday, December 29, 2019

There Is NO Such Thing as a “Paradox of Thrift” and Keynes Misrepresented the Classical Concept of Saving

In this article, I restate the classical savings theory of growth to provide a basis for demonstrating that Keynes misrepresented the classical concept of saving to include the hoarding of cash, a mistake which led to his erroneous conclusions about the classical theory of growth. I use Keynes's arguments mainly in the General Theory to restate the paradox of thrift proposition, and I rely on direct quotations from the classics and Marshall to establish Keynes's misrepresentation of their argument. I conclude that there is no such thing as a paradox of thrift other than Keynes's incorrect substitution of “hoarding” for “saving” in the classical theory of income determination. This recognition may help end the annual ritual of teaching students a fundamental confusion from which they later struggle to escape in courses such as development economics or finance. The discussion also shows that there is much of significance yet to be gained by paying careful attention to what the classics said, especially in assessing Keynes's claims against them. Even among the classics, as Samuelson has observed, “their quarrels lasted because often they were quarrels over misunderstandings and definitions.”

The classical theory of growth against which Keynes proposed his paradox of thrift argument simply states that economic growth is determined by the rate of saving or capital accumulation. The greater the amount saved out of income, the more capital goods, land, and labour services can be bought or hired for production.

—James C. W. Ahiakpor, “A Paradox of Thrift or Keynes's Misrepresentation of Saving in the Classical Theory of Growth?” Southern Economic Journal 62, no. 1 (July 1995): 17-18.